Prior to 2016-17, the OCCAC had a single all-academic team for the full school year. To be a member of the Academic All-OCCAC team prior to then, a student-athlete must have completed 24 credit hours with at least a 3.30 cumulative GPA.

2012-13

Women's Volleyball

Kathleen Beyoglides - Sinclair Community College (3.58 GPA)
Brianna Breeding - Sinclair Community College (3.43 GPA)
Shannon Digney - Lorain County Community College (3.548 GPA)
Ann Frieders - Edison Community College (4.0 GPA)
Molly Hilfinger - Owens Community College (3.74 GPA)
Ashley Howell - Columbus State Community College
Alyssa Meis - Owens Community College (3.32 GPA)
Ashley Nitsch - Columbus State Community College
Hannah Pinkie - Lorain County Community College (3.731 GPA)
Marie Rank - Sinclair Community College (3.55 GPA)
Brooke Reinke - Edison Community College (3.764 GPA)
Tori Shimp - Edison Community College (3.3 GPA)
Rebecca Slocum - Lakeland Community College (3.51 GPA)
Meredith Stuebbe - Lakeland Community College (3.63 GPA)
Jessica Thobe - Sinclair Community College (3.73 GPA)
Lisa Urbanski - Owens Community College (4.0 GPA)
Alyssa Woltman - Lakeland Community College (3.44 GPA) * 
Dominique Yates - Owens Community College (3.51 GPA)
Stephanie Ziegler - Lakeland Community College (3.48 GPA) 

Women's Basketball

Kelly Flanigan - Lakeland Community College (3.50 GPA)
Moran Huelskamp - Edison Community College (3.667 GPA)
Christine Johnson - Edison Community College (3.5484 GPA)
Grace McDougall - Cincinnati State Technical and Community College (3.8 GPA)
Brittany Morr - Lakeland Community College (3.75 GPA)
Emily Mowbray - Edison Community College (3.4 GPA)
Paige Newlon - Edison Community College (3.4 GPA)
Brooke Smith - Sinclair Community College (3.73 GPA)
Terra Vanover - Edison Community College (3.488 GPA)
Riley Weng - Sinclair Community College (3.34 GPA)
Stephanie Ziegler - Lakeland Community College (3.48 GPA) 

Men's Golf

Luke Berger - Owens Community College (3.73 GPA)
Roman King - Lorain County Community College (3.308 GPA)
Alex Roberts - Owens Community College (3.64 GPA)
Thomas Sanford - Lakeland Community College (3.52 GPA)
Ian Sooy - Lorain County Community College (3.310 GPA)

Men's Soccer

Michael Anthony - Cincinnati State Technical and Community College (3.9 GPA)
Tucker Beerman - Cincinnati State Technical and Community College (3.622 GPA)
Odaine Edwards - Owens Community College (3.50 GPA)
Alec Hradisky - Cuyahoga Community College (3.50 GPA)
Liam Doyle - Cincinnati State Technical and Community College (3.579 GPA)
Josh Kleinow - Owens Community College (3.40 GPA)
Austin Klueh - Cincinnati State Technical and Community College (4.0 GPA)
Tyler Kortokrax - Owens Community College (3.40 GPA)
Nick Merhaut - Cincinnati State Technical and Community College (3.543 GPA)
Justin Mitchell - Cincinnati State Technical and Community College (3.339 GPA)
Michael Maiorano - Lakeland Community College (3.32 GPA)
David Ortega-Gonzalez - Owens Community College (4.0 GPA)
Mark Primuth - Cuyahoga Community College (3.33 GPA)
Richard Vanhorne - Cuyahoga Community College (4.0 GPA) 
Sebastian Vieira - Lakeland Community College (3.68 GPA) 

Women's Soccer

Taylor Avers - Owens Community College (3.53 GPA)
Meghan Cook - Cincinnati State Technical and Community College (3.333 GPA)
Chelsey Hill-Root - Cincinnati State Technical and Community College (3.426 GPA)
Haley Kreger - Owens Community College (3.79 GPA)
Marissa Ramirez - Owens Community College (3.31 GPA)
Danielle Reifenberger - Cincinnati State Technical and Community College (3.6 GPA)
Sarah Weaver - Owens Community College (3.52 GPA) 

Softball

April DeCant - Owens Community College (3.63 GPA)
Molly Gast - Owens Community College (3.50 GPA)
Jaylee Glad - Owens Community College (3.55 GPA)
Melanie Iacoangeli - Owens Community College (3.88 GPA)
Kelly Kirkpatrick - Cuyahoga Community College (3.50 GPA)
Skylar Lund - Lakeland Community College (3.33 GPA)
Olivia Reeder - Owens Community College (3.34 GPA)
Kayla Schmidt - Cuyahoga Community College (3.55 GPA)
Hannah Shank - Owens Community College (3.75 GPA)
Amanda Sinay - Owens Community College (3.83 GPA)
Chantel Smithberger - Lakeland Community College (3.46 GPA)
Katilyn Turski - Owens Community College (3.32 GPA)
Taylor VanWinkle - Sinclair Community College (3.69 GPA)
Alyssa Woltman - Lakeland Community College (3.44 GPA) *

Baseball

Darwin Argumedo - Sinclair Community College (3.60 GPA)
Benjamin Breymier - Owens Community College (3.61 GPA)
Anthony Connacher - Lakeland Community College (3.70 GPA)
Andrew Cuffman - Cuyahoga Community College (3.93 GPA)
Dylan Danko - Cuyahoga Community College (4.0 GPA)
Dane Davis - Owens Community College (3.78 GPA)
Austin Downing - Sinclair Community College (3.30 GPA)
Michael Fry - Owens Community College (3.40 GPA)
Scott Haag - Sinclair Community College (3.58 GPA)
Nicholas Hoy - Cuyahoga Community College (4.0 GPA)
Bryan Murphy - Sinclair Community College (3.62 GPA)
Craig Koehler - Sinclair Community College (3.3 GPA)
Brock McGivern - Cuyahoga Community College (3.50 GPA)
Casey Roch - Cuyahoga Community College (3.59 GPA)
Jonathan Rose - Sinclair Community College (3.31 GPA)
Giancarlo Saia - Lakeland Community College (3.39 GPA)
Alex Samson - Owens Community College (3.61 GPA)
Dru Sebastian - Owens Community College (3.41 GPA)
Nicklaus Street - Owens Community College (3.77 GPA)
Adam Urbania - Cuyahoga Community College (3.30 GPA)
Justin Webb - Lakeland Community College (3.90 GPA) 
Matthew Zitny - Owens Community College (3.55 GPA) 

Men's Basketball

Deran Banton - Lakeland Community College (3.40 GPA)
Cody Begley - Owens Community College (3.50 GPA)
Mike Krempaski - Cuyahoga Community College (3.72 GPA)
Drew Moore - Sinclair Community College (3.37 GPA)
Reneillio Morrison - Owens Community College (3.30 GPA)
Marius Paulauskas - Lakeland Community College (3.88 GPA)